Stepping into the Sassafras Saloon felt like entering an underworld of sin and spectacle. I found myself immersed in a meticulously crafted narrative by creators Rachel Felstein and Christy Casey of The Last Supper Club. Their production, The Original Sin City, reimagines New Orleans’ historic Storyville district as a theatrical underworld, thick with mystery and anticipation.

Becoming Part of the World
For me, the experience began before stepping through the doors. The creators provided inspiration through mood boards, offering visual touchstones that helped me immerse myself in the aesthetic of this Storyville inspired world. Once inside, I appreciated how that preparation created a cohesive visual tapestry among the crowd. The audience felt like part of the world rather than a group of passive observers.
As the night unfolded, the strength of the production shone through its ensemble cast. I was particularly impressed by the performers’ collaboration. Their intricate character dynamics made the underworld feel populated by unique individuals with strongly intertwined histories.
The storytelling was structured around recurring scenes set within a brothel environment. This setting served as a narrative anchor, allowing me to revisit a key moment in the plot. With each iteration, I noticed subtle shifts that revealed new layers of character relationships and personal growth. Watching multiple cycles gave me a deeper understanding of the story.

Talent Beyond the Storytelling
The environment was amplified by the sheer caliber of talent present. Beyond their skills as improvisers and immersive actors, the variety show allowed the performers’ additional talents to shine. From music to visual spectacle, the performances extended throughout the space. Burlesque performers took to the bar, fire performances manipulated flames with hypnotic precision and aerialists defied gravity, adding dynamic levels to the immersive landscape. A live band added another layer to the evening’s atmosphere.
I also appreciated how special skills within the immersive story supported the characters’ personalities. The Greedy Swindler, for example, was played by the talented magician Nathaniel Segal, whose sleight of hand felt like a perfect addition to his role.

Personal Connections in the Underworld
Interactive elements like bingo cards encouraged us to engage with the experience. I found them to be an effective community-building tool, offering reasons to converse with strangers and guidance on ways to actively seek out interactions with the cast.
A particularly memorable example was my interaction with the Navy man, Oliver, played by Kyle Tague. Tague created a deeply personal moment when he pulled me aside for an intimate monologue. Delivered with heartfelt conviction in a quiet corner by the fireplace, this scene allowed me to connect with the character’s history and emotional struggle. It exemplified the type of profound, one-on-one engagement that I love in immersive theater.
Similarly, the Patron Saint of Wrath, portrayed by Georgia Warner, offered an opportunity for self-reflection that felt very organic in the storytelling. She invited me to reflect on personal sources of anger while holding an object. Rather than imposing a moral lesson, she offered a choice to release that burden, creating space for genuine reflection.
These narrative gems emerged naturally throughout my evening. I appreciated that emotional resonance received as much attention as spectacle.

Bringing the Story Together
The culmination of these threads occurred in a dramatic finale staged above the bar. This balcony scene wrapped up the repeating brothel drama, giving me a sense of closure to the overarching story. It served as a visual and narrative crescendo that felt more meaningful after the moments I had witnessed throughout the night.
Ultimately, what worked best for me was the balance between structured storytelling and spontaneous connection. Tools like bingo cards and mood boards helped make it easier to become an active participant in the experience. The intimate, unforced moments of self-reflection, paired with the undeniable talent of the performers, left a lasting emotional impression.
For all its sin and spectacle, it was the personal moments with the characters of this underworld that stayed with me.
There are no future events listed on the calendar at https://jointhelastsupperclub.com/ at this time, but I will be sure to announce any upcoming events here as well as on social media @thehauntgirl. Special thanks to The Last Supper Club for inviting me to Hell. I had a sinfully good time!
